Hotels or Airbnb: Which choice for Umrah?
The Umrah, a journey that goes beyond mere travel, is a moment of devotion and spirituality. But before you can turn around the Kaaba or walk between Safa and Marwah, there's an essential question to answer: where to stay in Makkah and Madinah? Hotels or Airbnb? Luxury or simplicity? Comfort or savings?
2/12/20253 min read
Making the right accommodation choice can transform your experience, providing the peace and rest you need to focus entirely on your rituals. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of each option so you can decide what suits you best.
1. Hotels: A Classic and Convenient Choice
Hotels remain the most popular option for Umrah pilgrims, and for good reason. Makkah and Madinah offer a wide range of hotels, from luxurious 5-star stays to budget-friendly options.
Advantages of Hotels
✅ Proximity to the Haram
Hotels near the Haram offer quick access to the Sacred Mosque, saving time and energy.
Some hotels, like the Makkah Clock Royal Tower or Hilton Suites, provide breathtaking views of the Kaaba, making every sunrise unforgettable.
✅ Comfort and Services
Most hotels offer essential services such as housekeeping, breakfast, shuttle services, and 24/7 reception. After a long day of rituals, returning to a clean, air-conditioned room is a true relief.
✅ Ideal for Groups
If you’re traveling with family, many hotels offer suites or connecting rooms, perfect for staying together while enjoying individual space.
✅ Spiritual Atmosphere
Being surrounded by fellow pilgrims creates a unique spiritual ambiance. Simply meeting other believers in the hotel lobby or at breakfast can enrich your experience.
Disadvantages of Hotels
❌ High Costs
During peak periods like Ramadan, hotel prices near the Haram can be exorbitant.
❌ Crowds
Popular hotels attract thousands of pilgrims, leading to crowded elevators and busy lobbies at peak times.
➡️ Ideal for:
Those who prioritize comfort, proximity, and a hassle-free experience—especially families or elderly travelers.
2. Airbnb: A Flexible and Budget-Friendly Alternative
In recent years, Airbnb has gained popularity, even for spiritual journeys like Umrah. Renting an apartment or house can be a great alternative, particularly for those who seek more flexibility.
Advantages of Airbnb
✅ Cost Control
Airbnb accommodations, especially those a bit further from the Haram, are often much more affordable than hotels.
You can find options for all budgets, with the ability to split costs if traveling in a group.
✅ More Space
Unlike a hotel room, an Airbnb often includes a kitchen, living room, and multiple bedrooms—ideal for large families or groups of friends.
✅ Independence
Cooking your own meals in a fully equipped kitchen can help you manage food expenses and eat at your own pace.
✅ Personalized Stay
Some local hosts offer valuable insights, such as the best times to avoid crowds or recommendations for authentic restaurants.
Disadvantages of Airbnb
❌ Distance from the Haram
Many Airbnb options are located outside the Haram area, requiring shuttle or taxi rides.
❌ Fewer Services
Unlike hotels, there’s no daily housekeeping or 24/7 reception assistance.
❌ Limited Availability
Airbnb options can be scarce, especially during peak seasons.
➡️ Ideal for:
Travelers on a budget, large groups, or those who prefer an independent stay.
3. Hotels vs. Airbnb: Key Factors to Consider
1. Proximity to the Haram
If being just minutes away from the Kaaba is your priority, hotels are usually the best option.
If you’re okay with a short commute, an Airbnb slightly farther away can be a budget-friendly choice.
2. Budget
For tight budgets, Airbnb is often the more economical choice.
Hotels near the Haram can be up to three times more expensive.
3. Comfort and Services
Hotels provide a hassle-free experience with convenient services that ease your journey.
Airbnb requires more independence but offers a home-like atmosphere.
4. Travel Type
Solo travelers or couples: Hotels are often more suitable, with convenient and affordable single-room options.
Families or groups: Airbnb offers more space and flexibility, making it ideal for group travel.
4. Combining Both: A Smart Approach
Why choose between a hotel and Airbnb when you can enjoy the best of both?
✅ Start with a hotel: If you arrive late or want to settle in quickly, book a few nights at a hotel near the Haram to focus on your initial rituals.
✅ Switch to an Airbnb: For longer stays, moving to an Airbnb can help you save money and enjoy more space.
5. Practical Tips for Making the Right Choice
For Hotels
✔️ Book early, especially for peak seasons like Ramadan.
✔️ Look for hotels with free shuttle services to save time and energy.
For Airbnb
✔️ Choose accommodations with positive reviews and responsive hosts.
✔️ Check the actual distance to the Haram and available transport options.
A Final Thought: Choose What Brings You Peace
Whether you opt for a hotel with a Kaaba view or a cozy Airbnb on the outskirts, remember that the essence of your journey lies not in where you sleep but in your intentions and acts of worship.
It’s not material comfort that will make your Umrah successful—it’s your connection with Allah.
Plan wisely, consider your needs and budget, but always leave room for trust in Allah. May He bless your journey and accept your devotion. Ameen.